MagicPost grades your audience. It just cannot write from your work
MagicPost is the only other product here that scores the people who engage with your posts against an ideal customer profile, and it does it well. If you have read that Inklined is alone in closing that loop, that is out of date.
The difference is upstream. MagicPost can tell you whether the people reading you are buyers. It cannot help you write from the work that would attract them.
Side by side
| MagicPost | Inklined | |
|---|---|---|
| Entry price | from $29 | £49 |
| Where the idea comes from | A topic, a URL or a file you supply | The calls you already had |
| Client seats and approvals | ||
| Getting material in | ||
| Connects to your call recorder | Granola, Fathom, Fireflies, Attio, or any recorder via webhook | |
| Works with a recorder they have not integrated | Webhook for any recorder | |
| YouTube, with the transcript | Transcript, via the extension | |
| Articles you read, in full | Full text, via the extension | |
| Podcasts | Captured, via the extension | |
| Newsletters you subscribe to | Your own forwarding address | |
| Your own documents | PDF, DOCX, TXT, MD | |
| Record straight into it | Audio or video, in the app | |
| Turn a long document into a set of pieces | Bodies of work into a set of pieces | |
| Import a back catalogue in one go | ||
| Your voice | ||
| A voice profile you can open and edit | Seven Markdown files you own | |
| Take it with you if you leave | Download as a zip | |
| Tells you how well it knows you yet | Scored 0 to 100, per file | |
| Interviews you to fill the gaps | Journalistic, voice or typed | |
| Learns from the edits you make | Your edits become proposed rules | |
| Every day | ||
| Tells you what to write about today | Four ranked questions, each cited | |
| Shows the evidence behind each prompt | The quote and link behind every prompt | |
| Finds posts worth commenting on | Posts worth replying to, vetted | |
| A feed of everything your sources found | ||
| A daily email that mirrors it | Daily email, at your chosen time | |
| A searchable library of other people’s posts | 2M+ post library | |
| Writing | ||
| Interviews you rather than just generating | AI post generator | It interviews you, then writes |
| Multiple angles on the same idea | Nine styles, three at a time | |
| Scores whether it sounds like you | Scored 0 to 100 against your voice | |
| Warns you when an idea is too thin | Tells you when material is thin | |
| Cites your own material in the draft | Grounded in your own calls and swipes | |
| Rewrite one line without regenerating | Highlight a line, rewrite just that | |
| AI-tell detection tuned to your writing | AI-tell detector tuned to your corpus | |
| Long form | ||
| Articles and newsletters, not just posts | Articles and newsletters | |
| Newsletter export to your own tool | Substack, beehiiv, Mailchimp | |
| Publish long-form to your blog | Articles to your own blog | |
| Publishing | ||
| One-click publish and scheduling | Via the official API | One click, or schedule |
| @mentions that resolve | ||
| Post as a company page | ||
| Stock image search built in | Unsplash and Pexels search | |
| Carousels and document posts | AI photos, carousels | |
| Video, clips and audiograms | ||
| Publishes anywhere but LinkedIn | ||
| Knowing if it worked | ||
| Per-post metrics | Impressions, reach, likes, comments, shares | |
| What is working, measured over your posts | Weekly, with confidence intervals (Pro) | |
| Whether the right people read it | Whether buyers actually read it | |
| The topics you never get round to | Including pillars you never write about | |
| Rate whether a post sounded like you | ||
| The people reading | ||
| Captures who engaged | Everyone who engages, captured | |
| Ranks them by warmth | Hot, warm, aware or cold, with trend | |
| Scores them against your buyer | Excellent to Low | Scored against your own ICP |
| Explains why | With the reasoning | |
| Pushes them to your CRM | HubSpot, Pipedrive, lemlist | HubSpot, Attio |
| Sequences them | Apollo, lemlist | |
| Pull engagers from anyone else’s post | From any post URL, not just your own | |
| Automates engagement: connects, DMs, comments | ||
| Making it a habit | ||
| Starts with a strategy session | 15-minute session, before you write | |
| A weekly review of what you learned | Friday review: camera, audio or text | |
| Next week planned and argued for | Next week, already argued for | |
| Holds you to what you committed to | Committed against published | |
MagicPost details taken from their own site on 20 September 2026. Inklined prices exclude VAT.
How does each one score the people who engage?
MagicPost asks you to describe your ideal customer in plain language, then compares each engager against location, company, industry, company size, follower count and job title, along with the comment they left. It returns a grade of Excellent, Good, Medium or Low, and pushes qualified people to HubSpot, Pipedrive or lemlist.
Inklined works the same way in shape. You describe the buyer, engagers get scored against it with the reasoning attached, and the qualified ones can go to Apollo or lemlist.
On that job alone, there is not much in it. If scoring your engagers is the only thing you want, MagicPost starts at $29 and is a mature product with a deep agency feature set.
So what is the actual difference?
Where the post comes from. MagicPost’s published inputs are a topic, a URL or a file. You bring the idea. It writes it well, schedules it through the official LinkedIn API, and grades who turns up.
Inklined starts from the calls you already ran. The framework you talked a client through on Tuesday is a draft on Wednesday, without you having to remember it happened or decide it was interesting.
For a consultant or fractional executive, that upstream half is usually the part that breaks. Scoring an audience is not much use if the reason you have no audience is that you never got round to posting.
When MagicPost is the better buy
If you run LinkedIn for other people, MagicPost is built for it and we are not. Client seats, approval workflows, white-label reports and per-seat agency pricing are all there.
If you want a cheap, mature engagement-scoring layer and you are happy supplying the topics yourself, it starts at $29 and does that job properly.
They also publish a great deal about operating through the official LinkedIn API rather than a browser extension, and describe themselves as a LinkedIn-verified partner. That is their claim rather than something we have confirmed, but account safety is a reasonable thing to care about and they address it directly.
The calls are already happening.
Start with the strategy session. No card needed for that part.